If I can't find a story about my specific situation in the Satcharitra, should I just stop reading it?

On the contrary, the guidance in Chapter 50 suggests that the value of reading the Satcharitra is not contingent on finding a story that perfectly matches your situation. The text emphasizes that when 'stories of Saints fall on the ears, not a trace of sin remains' and 'Merit sprouts from hearing the stories.' More importantly, it advises readers to cultivate a non-dual devotion and 'see them as one state'—the reader, the reading, and Sai. By focusing on this unity and maintaining humility, as Chapter 50 recommends, the act of hearing becomes fruitful. The benefit comes from the act of devoted reading itself, which purifies the heart.